Showing posts with label paradigms. Show all posts
Showing posts with label paradigms. Show all posts

12 December 2011

Final Reflection for my Course on Litearature and Media

Question: How do we reflect on our practices as critical educators of literature, language, and media?

Reflection: Over the course of the semester, we’ve been bombarded with mental stimuli from all directions, and we’ve been asked to reflect on the practices and genres we’ve been learning about as we’ve been learning, and to reflect on the feedback we’ve been receiving as we’ve been receiving it. In Lit and Media in particular, we’ve been learning briefly about tons of potential literacy practices and genres of media, and we’ve been reflecting on how we might teach them or use them in our own classrooms. However, the question of how we reflect on our practices is one that perhaps hasn’t been sufficiently addressed. Given the frequency with which we’re asked to reflect on our practices, the question of how best to do that merits some consideration.

Deborah Appleman (2010) described the process she went through when reflecting on her role as a reading teacher, so in that sense, she might serve as a model. When we read her text at the very beginning of the semester, I thought about what my role as an English teacher might be, and it made sense that teaching students to read—words, pictures, videos, or any number of texts—was most certainly a part of my role; Appleman made perfect sense. However, reflecting on my own practice proves more difficult.

In the “Classroom Connections” activities I completed for this class, I dealt with reflecting on my own practice as well. How had the strategies I implemented met the goals I had set out for them? Where did they fall short? Why did they fulfill the goals they were meant to, or fall short? I suppose these are good beginnings to reflections on my practice, but there’s a missing step, it seems, and it’s one I’ve danced around all semester, we’ve talked about in class to some extent, and I’m only now coming to any sort of an answer to: Why did I set the goals I set for the practice in the first place?

Dealing with this question, I think, is of critical importance, because how we set the goals of our classes is at the heart of our pedagogical identity. If I see my classroom as one in which I train students to be capable employees or prepared college students or master test takers, my instructional goals are going to be very different than if I see my classroom as a space for open inquiry and criticism of the social forces behind the texts we’re studying. My classroom, I hope, will fall into this latter category. But at what level should I stop reflecting?

In the other classes in this program, we read Peter Smagorinsky’s texts about unit planning—setting instructional goals, planning how best to assess those goals, determining learning goals for lessons that will prepare students for their assessment, and planning activities that will meet the learning goals of the lesson, so that students are sufficiently scaffolded to complete their unit assessment successfully. Much of our reflection in Lit and Media--our discussions of different genres or critical lenses, for example—has been on these levels. Some of the texts we’ve read have offered practical suggestions or sample lessons, while others have expounded upon the importance of various genres in the curriculum, the larger social issues the genres can speak to, etc.

When reflecting on our practice, then, should we be focusing on whether our learning goals were aligned with our assessments? Should we be focusing on ensuring that our goals for student learning match up with the pedagogies/ideologies we’ve established about the role of English Education in student lives, in our school communities, or in society at large? Or should we be reflecting on the validity of the pedagogy/ideology that guides our classroom, critically examining the assumptions we make every day about our students, our discipline, our world, and ourselves?

Like so many other questions we’ve raised this semester, I don’t claim to have a final answer to this question. As I’ve mentioned, the authors we’ve read this semester have dealt, really, with all of these levels of reflection, and I’m sure that each of them is important. But trying to balance all of them, reflect on all of them at any given time, at least at this stage in our teaching careers, can be totally overwhelming, at least for me. So is there a balance to be struck? I think that, most likely, this balance varies from educator to educator, from classroom to classroom, and from year to year and even day to day. But I also know that only once I started thinking about my role, my goals as an educator, I became more engaged and more motivated. Once I began reflecting on my own motives and reasons for the goals I’ve set as an educator and the role I see myself playing, I became excited again about the empowering possibilities of literacies, and that level of reflection motivated me when reflecting on my success or failure at managing behavior in a classroom or aligning formative assessments with learning goals had me totally bogged down.

And our inquiry discussions in class, at times, have addressed these questions. When we talk about the role of “dangerous” texts like Do The Right Thing, or of “dangerous” topics like violence, sexuality, race, or religion, we’ve been talking around how we see our role as educators, or the role of an English classroom, or the English teacher.

So, how do we reflect on our practices as critical educators of literature, language, and media? Again, I don’t think this class has brought me to a single conclusion, but it has highlighted the importance of reflection on a number of levels. Without “meta-reflection,” reflection on the ideology/ies behind the rationales, though, I think something is missing. It is at this level that I ought to begin, I think, to understand why I set the unit goals, or lesson-level learning goals that I set, or why I select the genres or texts that I select. This level of awareness will, if I can maintain it, make me a more responsible, and more accountable educator, and for this reason, this level of reflection is a necessary step in my reflection on my practice.


05 October 2011

What does/should Education look like?

Today, I observed another teacher's class, and it reminded me of some concerns I have about education broadly--not just specific to me/my program, but the way schools are structured. So this entry is perhaps to be a bit more philosophical, but I think it's of critical importance, at least to me, as I prepare to take my place in the American education system as we know it.

So, what I observed--I sat in on a 9th grade history class, as they worked on crafting a piece of historical fiction. Students started out the class by thinking about setting, and the class developed into a writing/illustrating (they were making posters to go with their compositions) workshop. Perhaps the students were learning quite a bit by thinking about a realistic, historically accurate character, and perhaps they weren't--it's hard for me to say, based on the single lesson I observed. That's not really the point of my inquiry, though, because what other teachers--English teachers--had to say about his lesson surprised me.

"Is this you fulfilling your long lost dream of being an English teacher?" they joked.

The teacher who led the lesson also offers an elective course called "military history" that investigates the wars in which the US has participated through reading and writing short stories as well as historical texts, which makes sense to me, because it provides a space that is desperately needed and, in my experience, rarely actualized, for content-area reading instruction. Students learn to read history books vs. short stories. He called it a "hybrid" English/History course.

Because of the importance of reading/writing to History (really, to all disciplines), I was really surprised by the English teachers' comments, good-natured as they were, because they revealed a real compartmentalization, even in the minds of educators, of education. But this isn't the first I've seen of this.

My mentor teacher frequently says things like "this is about as math-y as we're going to get in an English class" (when talking about syllogisms and formal logic) and "That looks like shapes and numbers, put it away, you're in English class," to which the student replied, "It's not math, it's physics," to which my mentor replied, "That's even worse, that's math, shapes, and science!" (When a student was working on physics homework during her English class). I'm certainly not saying that she should be more willing to teach math, or that she should let students work on other subjects while in her class--I'm simply pointing out the clear delineation of what "is" and "is not" English, History, Math, Science, etc.

And I was put in mind of some of the comments I heard two weeks ago from students when I was presenting my lesson to introduce them to the Enlightenment and the American Revolution, and I asked them to think of people/ideas/events that they knew of that related to this time period. I remember one student objecting, "Why do we have to do this? We're not in History class! I'm bad at history!"

But History and English are so related! And science and math, too, in various ways, to say nothing of the "non-accademic" disciplines, the arts, music, etc. All of these disciplines inform how we understand the others; without understanding quantifiable methods of determining value, the lists Thoreau makes in Walden mean nothing to us; the idea of Frost's "two roads diverged in a yellow wood...I took the one less traveled by," which asks us to consider the relationships between values of quantity and quality, would be meaningless, and the comparison wouldn't be there; without science, what would "The Birthmark" mean, how could it exist, or how could Frankenstein? So if we can clearly see the way we use information from all disciplines to make sense of the information we're asked to analyze in any one classroom, why do we insist on these delineation's?

Sir Ken Robinson, with the RSA, gives a much more articulate critique of American education than I can do justice. This video is super interesting and really made me think about why our schools are the way they are, why they're structured this way, and how they end up functioning:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U

For those of you not watching the video, what he argues is that the American school system is currently set up in the image of industrialization, producing "educated students" in batches, treating students as automatons, and knowledge as a single product that can be given to individual students, and then they simply have it (I think his critique comes close to the "transmission model" of education, where teachers have "truth" and can transmit it to students, eg through lectures and readings).

I think his critiques are really smart, and I think the relationship between the various disciplines--how they rely on one another and overlap--is some of the strongest evidence of the need to change the paradigm of the American school. But I have a really hard time imagining what the alternatives might look like. The closest I can come up with is something more like college, where students are allowed to excel at what they're good at--reading, preforming, calculating, etc--while collaborating with one another to enrich each other's understandings. But how do you group them? Surely you need to group them somehow? Age/grade level? Area in which they excel (which again presents the problem of how you determine/separate subjects/disciplines)? Some totally random/arbitrary grouping, so they have a diversity of peers to collaborate with? I'm at a loss...

So I know things need to change, but I'm also becoming a part of the paradigm, and I'm struggling with how I might challenge it in my classroom, without hurting my students chances in the world which is structured with the understanding of the current paradigm in mind (students have to have grades, for example, and be able to pass tests on grammar/vocab/reading comprehension--otherwise how will they get into college/get hired? Or maybe this doesn't necessarily follow...?)

But, I think what I observed today was the beginning of a slight paradigm shift, even if it's only on a small scale. The lines between two disciplines are being intentionally blurred. So that's a start, right? And I can certainly do that in my classroom by incorporating a variety of texts and allowing students to produce a variety of texts, and to collaborate with one another (and with other classes?). Hopefully these ideas are getting at something valuable--any thoughts?